HISTORYBLOG.MEATandTHREE.com
An interactive, historical record of
cafe's, restaurants and diners
serving '1 meat and 3 vegetable' menu items



Welcome! Join in and take part in helping to write the history and stories of Meat and Three's all across the country.

New Amy's Diner in Old Hickory, TN

Print the article

This entry was posted on 12/5/2006 3:41 PM and is filed under Tennessee, Announcements.

On my visit to Maisie’s Restaurant in Old Hickory, Tennessee last week, I took an alternate route coming home, and noticed something was different along the way. The former Old Hickory Restaurant was closed, but a new Meat and Three was open in its place - Amy’s Diner [http://www.meatandthree.com/tn/amysdiner/].

Amy Stevens may or may not be a name that you immediately recognize, but the Blue Goose Café is probably one you would know if you have ever spent any time in Hendersonville, Tennessee. Amy was the owner of the Blue Goose for eight years, up until this past April. Thinking that she might make a career change, Amy sold the Blue Goose to enable that change. However, a few months later, someone told Amy about a place that was for sale in Old Hickory. Seeing the potential for growth and recognizing the challenge that the new opportunity would bring, Amy purchased the former Old Hickory Restaurant, changed the name to Amy’s Diner, and opened in August 2006.

In most new ventures, one cannot generally go it alone, and Amy’s case is no different. She has assistance from some of the people who were with her before. Before talking with Amy today, I was greeted and taken care of by Stacy, one of the waitresses who was with Amy at the Blue Goose (the other one is Ashley). I also found out that Amy’s mom comes in on Wednesdays to make the fried chicken.

I am sure this new venture will take some getting used to for Amy, since the Blue Goose was on the busy main thoroughfare in Hendersonville. The location in Old Hickory is a little more out of the way, yet the customer traffic is already a mix of “new” regulars as well as a steady stream of folks who have seen the well-placed signs in various places, in addition to the free “word-of-mouth“ advertising that is taking place. Once the word really gets out that Amy is in her new digs, there is sure to be a group of “old” regulars that flock to visit this new Old Hickory meat and three.

The interior did not seem to be too different from what I remember the Old Hickory Restaurant looking like, although it had been a while since I was there. The building has housed a café/restaurant for many years. As I have said many times about other places, this café is kind of typical meat and three - nothing fancy. The L-shaped dining room has wood-paneled walls, a tile floor and about 15 tables, of varying sizes. There is a white board that lists the daily meat specials, but not a lot else on the walls. The focus here is on the food, not so much on the décor.

Speaking of food, I ordered the baked chicken with gravy over rice, mashed potatoes, squash casserole, corn bread and sweet tea. There were 3 meat choices today and about 15 different veggie choices. Between the two dessert choices, chess pie and coon dog cake, Amy talked me into the coon dog cake. It is comprised of yellow cake mix, pineapple, cream cheese frosting, and pecans. I did not really inquire into how it got its name - all I know is that, in typical southern comfort food fashion, the little piece that I asked Amy for was not too small. Of course, I didn’t mind one bit. My wife, mother, mother-n-law, sister, and just about every other true Southern cook I know makes sure that you get a suitable piece of pie or cake at the end of the meal.

Hey, nothing wrong with a siesta on a Tuesday afternoon … right?
 

What did you think of this article?




Trackbacks
Trackback specific URL for this entry
  • No trackbacks exist for this post.
Comments

    • 3/19/2007 4:56 PM Lindsay wrote:
      This article is awesome yet it does not give you the full experience of the mouthwatering food that you will taste if you eat at this diner.
      Reply to this
    • 3/19/2007 7:37 PM Phil Roberson wrote:
      Lindsay, thanks for the comment. When I decided to start this blog, I thought long and hard about how to talk about the food itself. I ultimately decided to focus the articles on the Meat and Threes themselves and to not give my own opinion on the food. It was a tough choice because I really like to talk about good food when I eat it.

      Since there can be many different opinions about the same food eaten at the same restaurant by any number of people, I made the choice to leave the reviews of the food to the professionals who write and report this information in various media. My articles would talk about the buildings, the history, the stories, and about anything else except my opinions about the food. Listing what I ate, and what the person(s) with me ate, would be the extent of my mention of the food.

      Recording my articles in this fashion and bringing attention to the particular Meat-n-Threes themselves allows viewers to form their own opinions of the food once they have visited the restaurants that sound interesting to them. If they like one, they will likely go back and tell friends and family about their experience. My idea is to let the viewers decide rather than hear about my own preferences. Besides, I am probably not as picky as a lot of folks are, and am likely to be a bit more forgiving than many patrons. Additionally, since I am the owner and creator of the MEATandTHREE.com web site (sponsor of the blog), I am probably not the best person to be reviewing individual Meat and Threes.

      I hope that helps, Lindsay. Your input is greatly appreciated and taken with all seriousness!

      Phil Roberson (mn3guy)
      Reply to this
    • 9/7/2007 10:54 AM Phil Roberson wrote:
      I am sorry to report that Amy's Diner is now closed. Not sure what happened there, but I enjoyed my visits there.

      There is a new meat and three that has opened up in the same place - Ma & Pa's Diner [http://www.meatandthree.com/tn/maandpaskettle/]. I have not been there yet, so don't know anything about it.
      Reply to this
      1. 9/13/2007 5:17 AM larry meeks wrote:
        Finally, a restaurant that brings the taste of food back to the days of Grandmas dinner table. Seems like by the taste they cook everything from scratch. You have to try this place - the food is great. Phone number is 847-5003.
        Reply to this
    Leave a comment

    Submitted comments are subject to moderation before being displayed.

     Enter the above security code (required)

     Name (required)

     Email (will not be published) (required)

     Website

    Your comment is 0 characters limited to 3000 characters.